Greatness, Unexpectedly Delivered. The New York Yankees may have made headlines by acquiring star closer Devin Williams this past offseason, but it’s Luke Weaver — the unheralded journeyman — who’s emerged as the bullpen’s standout.
What began as a season full of questions in the relief corps has found stability in the most unexpected place.
**A Breakout No One Predicted**
When the Yankees signed Weaver to a low-profile two-year, \$4.5 million contract, few expected him to make much of a difference. After bouncing from team to team, consistency had always eluded him — until he donned the pinstripes.
In 2024, Weaver delivered a 2.89 ERA over 84 innings, then elevated his game in the playoffs, posting a 1.76 ERA over 15.1 innings. While Williams initially struggled, Weaver became the go-to option in high-pressure moments.
Now in 2025, he’s taken things to another level.
Dominance by the Numbers
Weaver owns a stunning 0.40 ERA through 22.2 innings this season, with a WHIP of just 0.53. He ranks among the league’s best in virtually every advanced stat for relievers.
Despite not holding the official closer role, he’s shutting down crucial innings with consistent, elite-level performances.
**A Case for an Extension**
At 31, Weaver likely has a few prime seasons remaining. Considering his current form and seamless fit with the team, the Yankees would be wise to lock him in with a two- or three-year extension.
With his contract set to expire after 2025, keeping a cost-effective and high-performing arm like his in the Bronx feels like a no-brainer — especially since Weaver wants to remain a Yankee.
**A Bullpen on the Rise**
With Jonathan Loáisiga healthy again and Williams rounding into form, the Yankees bullpen is evolving into a dominant trio. Weaver’s versatility gives manager Aaron Boone the luxury of deploying him in any late-inning, high-leverage situation.
And with October in mind, Weaver’s proven postseason poise only adds to his value.
He’s no longer a surprising contributor — he’s a crucial piece of the Yankees’ championship puzzle.
